Why Newcastle’s new Guimaraes & Tonali must start ahead of Joe Willock


Losing two core members of your squad in the form of Bruno Guimarães and Sandro Tonali was always going to make the 2026/27 campaign a tricky one for Newcastle United.

However, Matthias Jaissle has struggled more than more would have anticipated, with the 38-year-old unable to provide a feel good factor and impressive results after replacing Eddie Howe.

Many would argue the German is still yet to decide his best starting eleven after his appointment, which has contributed to the Magpies’ 11th place standing after the first seven Premier League outings.

Newcastle manager Matthias Jaissle-1 REUTERS/Scott Heppell

That being said, he clearly sees one senior member of the squad as key asset, but such a decision has left a large portion of the fanbase scratching their heads in recent weeks.

Why Jaissle has got it all wrong with Joe Willock at Newcastle

After starting just 10 league games last campaign and with just a year left on his current contract, many Newcastle supporters would have expected midfielder Joe Willock to be sold last summer.

However, despite receiving offers from Besiktas for the £20m man, Jaissle stated his desire to keep the Englishman and include him in his senior plans this term.

joe-willock-newcastle-liverpool Action Images via Reuters/Lee Smith

He’s already managed to start in 72% of games this campaign and been utilised as a substitute in the other 28% – something which has left supporters puzzled.

The 27-year-old has netted two league goals already this campaign, but such numbers don’t tell the full story – as his underlying figures make for grim reading.

Willock has only been able to create an average of 0.6 chances per 90 in England’s top-flight this term, a figure which places him below 80% of other midfielders in the division.

PL mins for Newcastle CMs (2026/27)

Rank

Player

PL minutes

1

Lewis Miley

548

2

Joe Willock

402

3

Nico González

347

4

Sean Steur

225

5

Joelinton

120

6

Aladji Bamba

27

Without the ball, the former Arsenal man has been just as ineffective this campaign, subsequently making just 2.2 ball recoveries per 90 – a figure placing him in the bottom 8% for players in Europe.

His figures demonstrate his lack of quality at both ends of the pitch, and begs the question – why does Jaissle continuously keep selecting him in his starting eleven?

Why Newcastle’s new Bruno & Tonali will be frustrated at Jaissle

Asking Willock to emulate the levels produced Guimaraes and Tonali is impossible, with the Englishman undoubtedly a huge level below the pair in terms of quality.

The hierarchy were resigned to losing the pair during the recent summer transfer window, but did manage to hand Jaissle new additions to soften the blow.

However, the likes of Aladji Bamba and Sean Steur have been unable to showcase their talents at St James’ Park since their arrivals during the recent window.

The manager’s decision to utilise Willock has impacted their game time massively as of late, with the aforementioned duo only featuring for 252 minutes combined to date.

Whilst the pair are 20 and 18 respectively, they will have plenty of time to star on Tyneside, but the manager may be missing a trick in not including them straight into his senior plans.

Aladji Bamba for Newcastle REUTERS/Pablo Morano

French star Bamba has all the tools to become Newcastle’s next version of Tonali, with the youngster able to sit in front of the backline and operate as a dominant ball-winner.

During his final season as a Monaco player, the 20-year-old managed to make a staggering 3.6 tackles and 6.1 defensive contributions – both ranking him in the top 15% of all midfielders in Europe’s top-five leagues.

However, his continued snub by Jaissle has prevented him from continuing his promising start to his career, which no doubt will anger the talent after his big-money move to the North East.

As for Steur, he’s at least been trusted to start two league games this campaign, but will still be disheartened that players like Willock continue to be selected ahead of him.

Despite his limited action this campaign, the Dutch star has showcased that he’s capable of developing into the club’s next Guimaraes with his tremendous efforts at both ends of the pitch.

The teenager has managed to create 1.4 chances per 90 from his deep-lying position and often been the pace setter at the heart of the side when selected by Jaissle.

sean-steur-newcastle-liverpool REUTERS/Scott Heppell

Such chances have come as a result of his 10.1 line-breaking passes per 90 – a part of Guimaraes’ game which made him a monster hit with supporters on Tyneside.

However, despite impressing when handed the chance, Steur has largely had to settle for cameos off the bench to showcase his talents in the Premier League.

He and Bamba are two highly-promising players who could well make the club millions in the years ahead, but only if the manager hands the game time needed to progress further.

Starting Willock over the pair of them will no doubt anger the duo after their big-money moves, but will only stagnate their progress and heighten the chances of the hierarchy losing a fortune.



Source link