What happens when an employee faces criminal allegations
- As the business owner, you may be inclined to dismiss member of staff facing the allegations. However, a hasty response may create problems for any later employment tribunal and for the criminal investigation itself.
- Check employment contracts before you decide to suspend the employee. If they do not include a right to suspend, you will need take advice before acting. Whichever route you take, explain it to the employee in writing and keep a record of your reasons.
- Where allegations are serious, it can be worth asking an independent criminal lawyer to carry out the investigation. They’re able to add weight to internal investigations and interview witnesses as well as keep records.
Growing businesses often rely on a small and essential team of people to build and drive the business forward, and few things can be more unsettling than learning that a member of the team has been accused of a criminal offence.
Whether relating to something at work, such as theft or harassment, or something in their private life that you hear about second hand, business owners will worry about the safety of colleagues, the reaction of customers and the cost to the business.
Depending on the nature of the alleged offence there is the very real chance the police will be knocking on your door. So, what happens when company disciplinary procedures and police investigations merge?
Larger organisations will have HR teams to lean on. In owner-managed businesses, it is often the managing director dealing with it, alongside everything else. The instinct is to act fast and dismiss that member of staff. But a hasty response may create problems for any later employment tribunal and for the criminal investigation itself.
Different rules, different timetables
Internal disciplinary processes and police investigations are, quite understandably, separate processes, running to different rules and timetables. But they do overlap, and what you do in one can affect the other.
The notes of any meetings, witness statements, emails and investigation reports may later be requested by the police and used as evidence. If they are incomplete, careless or biased, they could undermine a prosecution or be used against you if that employee later brings a claim.
The first question facing employers is whether the employee should remain at work while the matter is investigated. Suspension can protect colleagues and stop evidence being interfered with, but should not be viewed as punishment. It should normally be on full pay and kept as short as possible.
However, first check employment contracts. If they do not include a right to suspend, you will need to tread carefully and take advice before acting. Whatever you decide, explain it to the employee in writing and keep a record of your reasons.
You don’t have to wait for the courts
The criminal justice system is under severe strain and it can take months, sometimes years, for the police to reach a charging decision, let alone come before the courts. Businesses simply cannot keep someone suspended on full pay for that long.
The good news is that ACAS guidance is clear: employers do not usually need to wait for the outcome of a criminal case before reaching their own decision. That said, it is important to remember that a police investigation, or even a charge, is not in itself a reason to dismiss someone.
The reason being that the two processes apply different tests. A criminal court must be sure of guilt. An employer only needs a reasonable belief, based on a reasonable investigation, that misconduct took place. So, someone acquitted in court could still be fairly dismissed for the same conduct, and someone never charged could still face a disciplinary sanction.
Employees are broadly expected to cooperate with workplace investigations. But that can change where a criminal investigation is underway. Here, the employee might be represented by their own criminal lawyer and be advised to remain silent during any internal investigation in case it prejudices the police investigation.
Here, you may need to pause internal processes while the police investigate. But, if there are other workplace concerns separate to that criminal investigation or that do not impact the work of the police, it may be possible to deal with them separately. You can reach a decision on the employee’s future with the business based on the information you have to discipline or dismiss the employee. But remember, you do need to follow a fair procedure which includes giving that employee a fair opportunity to respond.
Get the right help early
Where allegations are serious, it can be worth asking an independent criminal lawyer to carry out the investigation. They can add weight to internal investigations and interview witnesses as well as keep records in a way that, should these records need to be disclosed, they will comply with the investigatory standards so they can be relied upon in any proceedings.
HR and police investigations are separate but will run side by side, and a business needs one joined up strategy. Getting both right starts with taking the good advice, before the first conversation with the employee, not after things have gone awry. Criminal and employment specialists working together can be valuable partners.
Stephanie Roe is a partner and criminal law specialist and Howard Lewis-Nunn a partner and barrister in the employment law team at Orwins.
Read more
10 ways to handle a workplace conflict – Conflicts can be inevitable in office environments, so when a heated argument does break out it’s important to resolve it quickly. Here are ten tips to help stop the issue
Mediation services for growing businesses – Save yourself the extra trouble of a cumbersome dispute by going down the mediation route. Katarina Morgan explains more