Sunderland’s perfect Brobbey replacement is warming the bench
Sunderland finally return to action in the Premier League this afternoon after two weeks without a match for the final international break of the calendar year.
The Black Cats travel away from the Stadium of Light to take on Aston Villa today, as they look to record back-to-back wins after their 1-0 victory over Chelsea before the break.
Regis Le Bris will be without two of his starters from that game, though, as Brian Brobbey and Granit Xhaka are both set to miss out through injury.
The Dutch centre-forward’s absence means that the French boss has to make a big decision up front, and he should opt against bringing Wilson Isidor into the starting line-up.
Why Isidor should not replace Brobbey
The Haiti international is the most experienced striker available to the Black Cats today, but he should be left out of the side because of his struggles in front of goal.
Isidor has failed to deliver a goal or an assist in any of his last seven appearances for club and country, whilst he has only scored one goal in 11 outings in all competitions for Sunderland this season.
His only goal contribution of the 2026/27 campaign so far came in a 1-0 win over Fulham at the Stadium of Light back in August, and he has gone nine matches without a goal or an assist since then.
The 26-year-old attacker has not proven that he can be relied upon as a starter in the Premier League, as he has not offered enough quality in or out of possession.
|
26/27 Premier League |
Wilson Isidor |
|---|---|
|
Appearances |
8 |
|
xG |
2.24 |
|
Goals |
1 |
|
Big chances created |
0 |
|
Assists |
0 |
|
Pass accuracy |
58% |
|
Duel success rate |
37% |
|
Aerial duel success rate |
24% |
Isidor has been dominated by defenders in physical duels, particularly aerially, struggled to find consistency as a finisher, and has been an underwhelming passer, which has played a part in his lack of creativity.
Therefore, Le Bris should not bring him into the starting line-up today because he does not look like the ideal player to replace Brobbey against Villa.
Sunderland’s Brobbey replacement is warming the bench
Instead of unleashing Isidor this afternoon, the French boss should finally start a young talent who has been warming the bench so far this season.
Sunderland swooped to sign 18-year-old centre-forward Juan Riquelme Angulo in the summer transfer window, and he looks like he could be the perfect replacement for Brobbey.
Speaking about the striker in his pre-match press conference this week, Le Bris said: “He’s a really good finisher, he’s agile, powerful. Until we don’t give him the opportunity, we won’t know. But what we see every day is encouraging.”
The French boss has clearly been impressed by what he has seen in training, hence why he raved about his qualities, and his description of the teenager could also be applied to Brobbey, as he is also a powerful and mobile number nine.
As Le Bris said, though, Sunderland will not know just how good he is until he is given an opportunity to play, which is why the striker should be unleashed from the start this afternoon.
Angulo has only played nine minutes in the Premier League so far this season, having made his debut off the bench against Brighton, and he has spent more time warming the bench, 261 minutes, than he has spent on the pitch.
|
Since signing for Sunderland |
|
|---|---|
|
Opposition |
Juan Angulo |
|
Chelsea |
Not in squad |
|
Coventry |
Not in squad |
|
Leeds |
Unused substitute |
|
Bournemouth |
Unused substitute |
|
Brighton |
9 |
The 18-year-old attacker’s form for Independiente del Valle, however, suggests that he has the potential to be a perfect Brobbey replacement if given more minutes to shine.
Angulo, who was tracked by Barcelona and Manchester United before his move to Wearside, scored six goals in 20 first-team games for his former club in the first half of the 2026 campaign.
The £5m-rated marksman scored six goals in seven LigaPro Serie A starts for Independiente del Valle, whilst also creating three ‘big chances’ and supplying three assists for his teammates.
On top of his goalscoring exploits, which suggest that he could have a Brobbey-esque impact in the final third, the teenage ace won 43% of his duels and completed 79% of his attempted passes.
These statistics suggest that Angulo has the potential to offer more to the team than Isidor as a well-rounded centre-forward because he can excel as a passer, a creator, and as a physical outlet in duels, which is where the ex-Zenit star struggles.
Therefore, Le Bris should replace Brobbey by bringing the £5m summer signing into the starting line-up against Aston Villa, because his technical and physical profile suggests that he is the closest like-for-like replacement in the squad.