Man Utd hold talks to sign £80m defender who’s better than Calvin Bassey
Manchester United may have a new manager in the form of Mauricio Pochettino but matters are not going to improve unless they work out a finer recruitment strategy.
In the summer of 2025, it was about strengthening the attack. In came Matheus Cunha, Bryan Mbeumo and Benjamin Sesko.
Last summer was about the midfield. Andrey Santos, Youri Tielemans and Carlos Baleba all arrived. Bizarrely, they have neglected the defence. That is now undoubtedly the biggest issue for Pochettino to fix.
One way of doing so could be to sign Calvin Bassey from Fulham.
The latest on Man Utd’s hunt for Calvin Bassey
Man United’s current predicament is evidenced by the quality of players they are pursuing ahead of the January transfer window, with Brentford’s Nathan Collins and Fulham’s Bassey on their radar.
Once upon a time, this was a club that signed Rio Ferdinand from Leeds for a pretty penny, a side that lured Raphael Varane away from Real Madrid.
Now, they are reduced to signing handy, albeit rather mediocre Premier League players. It’s worrying, particularly as United’s riches aren’t quite what they were anymore.
Under Sir Jim Ratcliffe, they have spent, but it has been more frugal than previous regimes. It explains why someone like Bassey is in their crosshairs, rather than someone like Alessandro Bastoni at Inter, for instance.
Alas, the Nigerian is the man they have chosen and a deal, should they pursue it, would be likely in January.
Fabrizio Romano revealed the latest on their pursuit just a matter of days ago, saying: “It’s true, there are people at Manchester United who appreciate Bassey.”
Romano continued: “This is a name they have had under consideration for a few months. They are following his performances and they like his physicality.”
Why Man Utd want to sign Calvin Bassey
Well, if you weren’t already aware, United are in a relegation fight. They sit 18th in the table and come kick off with Liverpool on Sunday, they could be sat bottom of the league. That’s a remarkable fact.
What hasn’t helped is their defensive record. They have shipped 19 goals. Only 20th-placed Crystal Palace and 14th-placed Ipswich Town have conceded more this term.
Furthermore, only three teams – Palace, Ipswich and Aston Villa – have conceded more xG than United’s tally of 17.9. They are in a mire and they need a solution quickly.
Bassey, aged 26, is approaching the prime of his career and could be just the tonic. He’s Premier League proven, he’s left-footed, he’s aggressive and really, he’s competent.
Sure, he may not be the star name United supporters are used to seeing arrive but he’s certainly more consistent than the likes of Lisandro Martinez and Ayden Heaven.
Only 11% of Premier League centre-backs have reached a higher running speed this season while he ranks among the finest 7% of positionally similar players for successful dribbles. He’s brilliant at progressing play and breaking through the lines. Call him something of an early Harry Maguire in that regard.
Yet, might there be a better signing on the horizon? Let’s take a look.
How Man Utd can sign an upgrade on Bassey
Bassey has his positives, of course he does, but there is a certain taboo around signing a defender from Fulham who has not exactly made waves since arriving at Craven Cottage.
So, how about someone else? Sky Germany report this week that, amid an £80m price tag, Man United have held early talks with Newcastle United regarding centre-back Malick Thiaw.
At that price, a deal is unlikely to be feasible, but on paper, it’s certainly a more eye-catching deal than Bassey.
While he has only been playing in the Premier League for just over a season now, he is proven in England and has proven to be one of Newcastle’s finest signings of the PIF era.
Last term, he was being celebrated as a potential £100m player and, at 25, he’s got one year on Bassey. While that final point may not mean much, you only need to look at the Swiss’ performances from 2025/26 to see why he’d be a higher calibre signing.
|
Bassey vs Thiaw in 2025/26 Premier League |
||
|---|---|---|
|
Stats (per 90 mins) |
Bassey |
Thiaw |
|
Non-penalty goals |
0.04 |
0.12 |
|
Shots |
0.46 |
0.85 |
|
Deep progressions |
0.25 |
0.33 |
|
Successful dribbles |
0.36 |
0.24 |
|
Progressive carries |
0.96 |
0.79 |
|
Progressive passes |
3.02 |
3.73 |
|
Tackles & interceptions |
2.24 |
2.12 |
|
Ball recoveries |
4.91 |
3.95 |
|
Aerial duels won |
1.39 |
3.43 |
|
Clearances |
1.88 |
2.90 |
Indeed, while Bassey is an expert at driving through the lines with the ball at his feet, amassing more successful dribbles and more progressive passes per 90 minutes, it is Thiaw who thrived in most other areas last season.
A pass is considered progressive if the distance between the starting point and the next touch is at least 10 meters closer to the opponent’s goal or any completed pass into the penalty area.
He was more progressive as far as his passing was concerned, and vitally, for a team that saw a goal threat in Casemiro depart over the summer, Thiaw will also offer you something from set pieces.
He’s a monster in the air, winning nearly two more aerial duels per 90 and he registered more non-penalty goals as well as shots.
Of course, United will sign Thiaw for his defensive ability first and foremost and in that regard, he’s strong too. This is a player who will get his head on pretty much everything.
Under Poch, the Red Devils certainly need a bit more of that.