3/10 Sunderland star is permanently heading for the bench


Sunderland failed to make their way out of the relegation zone after they were held to a 0-0 draw by Aston Villa in the Midlands on Saturday.

The Black Cats would have moved out of the bottom three, at least temporarily, if they had found a winner against Unai Emery’s side this weekend.

regis-le-bris-sunderland-aston-villa REUTERS/Chris Radburn

Regis Le Bris‘ side have now only won two of their 11 matches in the Premier League this season and will need to improve their form if they want to avoid a return to the Championship next year.

A draw with the Villans was not the worst result for the Black Cats, though, because Villa have only lost three times in the division so far this term.

How Sunderland’s draw with Aston Villa unfolded

It was a point earned through dogged defending and spirit because the home side totally dominated the match, enjoying 73% possession and taking 19 shots on goal.

chemsdine-talbi-sunderland REUTERS/Chris Radburn

Emery’s men seemed to be first to every second ball and generated plenty of shooting opportunities around the edge of the box, but the Black Cats defended deep and prevented too many chances within their own box.

Thankfully, for Sunderland, Villa were unable to take advantage of the chances that they did have to find the back of the net, despite eight of their efforts testing the goalkeeper.

Chemsdine Talbi then had the best chance of the game for Sunderland on a counter-attack late on, only for the winger to send his effort high and wide of the post after cutting in on his right foot.

How Robin Roefs stole the show against Aston Villa

Robin Roefs was the standout performer for Le Bris on Saturday because he kept a clean sheet under severe pressure, facing eight shots on target in total.

Vs Aston Villa

Robin Roefs

Minutes

90

Saves made

8

Goals prevented

+0.39

High claims

1

Run-out success rate

100%

Punches

1

Ball recoveries

13

The Netherlands international was solid as a rock between the sticks for Sunderland, preventing 0.39 xG in total, and was perfectly positioned to recover the ball 13 times in the 90 minutes.

His only questionable moment came in the first half when he played a pass into midfield that found Emi Buendia, but he recovered instantly to get back and catch the shot with ease.

Robin-Roefs

The Black Cats number one helped his side to earn a point with his display in goal, making a couple of impressive stops either side of the break, and he deserves the plaudits this weekend.

Saved by Roefs: 3/10 Sunderland star must be permanently benched

Roefs earning the draw perhaps saved other players from coming under more fire than they would have done if Sunderland had lost the game, and Wilson Isidor is one of those who should be grateful for his teammate’s showing.

With Brian Brobbey out through injury, the Haiti international was selected to lead the line for the Black Cats ahead of Juan Angulo and Timur Tutierov.

The former Zenit marksman will always provide tireless running and work rate at the top end of the pitch, to his credit, but the quality of his work on and off the ball left too much to be desired.

Rating Sunderland starters vs Aston Villa

Player

Rating

Robin Roefs

8

Thomas Meunier

6

Nordi Mukiele

7.5

Luke O’Nien

7

Reinildo

6.5

Jules Ahoka

7

Noah Sadiki

8

Trai Hume

6

Enzo Le Fee

6

Chemsdine Talbi

5

Wilson Isidor

3

Working hard physically is admirable, but it has to be effective. Isidor lost 75% (9/12) of his duels, committed five fouls, and lost 100% (4/4) of his aerial duels in the game.

As much as he pressed and put himself about, Aston Villa’s defenders found it far too easy to get the better of the centre-forward, which contributed to their domination of possession because Sunderland lacked a focal point up front.

Sunderland's Wilson Isidor

Isidor, whose only goal of the season came against Fulham in August, also failed to register any shots on target and did not create any chances for his teammates, as he ended the game with more offsides (two) than shot-creating actions (zero) for the Black Cats.

Five of his seven goals for Sunderland in the Premier League have come as a substitute, and he has not scored as a starter since the 2-1 win at Stamford Bridge against Chelsea in October 2025.

The 26-year-old attacker has not been effective as a starter in the top-flight since the start of last season, scoring two goals in his last 11 starts and going over a year without a goal as a starter, whilst he has not assisted a single goal in that time.

wilson-isidor-sunderland-brighton Action Images via Reuters/Lee Smith

He may have been saved from contributing to a loss by Roefs’ performances, but Le Bris should still permanently bench the experienced striker for the rest of the Premier League campaign.

Isidor is far more effective, as clearly evidenced by his statistics, when coming off the bench and that is the role that he should exclusively play for Sunderland moving forward.



Source link