How Newcastle have wasted £51m on star who looks like the new Almiron


Newcastle United finally got back to winning ways in the Premier League on Sunday with a 2-0 win against Crystal Palace at Selhurst Park.

The Magpies had lost 4-1 to Coventry and 1-0 to Aston Villa in their previous two outings in the top-flight, but they bounced back to secure the win against the Eagles.

willock-osula-newcastle Reuters/Andrew Couldridge

Despite spending £272m on attacking players since the start of last season, it was Harvey Barnes and Will Osula, who joined in 2023 and 2024 respectively, who scored the goals on Sunday.

Too many of the club’s expensive attacking recruits in recent transfer windows are going down the same path that Miguel Almiron went down at St. James’ Park.

Why Miguel Almiron was a Newcastle flop

At the end of the winter transfer window in 2019, Newcastle swooped to sign the Paraguay international from Atlanta United for what was a club-record fee of £21m at the time.

Almiron

The left-footed attacking midfielder did not hit the ground running with the Magpies, unfortunately, as he failed to score in ten Premier League appearances in the second half of the 2018/19 campaign.

Almiron’s form in the following three seasons was not much better, either, as he racked up nine goals and three assists in his first 110 games in the English top-flight.

Season

Appearances

Goals + assists

24/25

9

0 + 0

23/24

33

3 + 1

22/23

34

11 + 2

21/22

30

1 + 0

20/21

34

4 + 1

19/20

36

4 + 2

18/19

10

0 + 0

He had a purple patch in the 2022/23 campaign, scoring 11 goals in the division, but a return of 12 goals and four assists in 152 league games either side of that season shows that he was a flop overall.

Almiron arrived as a club-record signing and never established himself as a consistent and reliable attacking force before his return to Atalanta in January 2025.

How Newcastle flop is looking like the new Almiron

Now, one of the club’s signings from the recent summer transfer window is already starting to look like Newcastle’s latest version of Almiron in the final third.

The Magpies looked to strengthen their options at the top end of the pitch and committed a fee of £51m to bring Matias Fernandez-Pardo in from Lille on a permanent deal.

In the 2025/26 campaign, the Belgium international scored eight goals and missed 15 ‘big chances’ in 29 appearances in Ligue 1 for the French side, whilst he also provided five assists.

Newcastle were not put off by his incredibly wasteful finishing numbers in the French top-flight, though, and went through with signing him for a mammoth fee this summer.

Yoane Wissa and Matias Fernandez-Pardo Reuters/Lee Smith

Just a couple of months into his career on Tyneside, Matthias Jaissle and his staff may already be starting to wonder whether or not they made a mistake with the 21-year-old forward.

Fernandez-Pardo, who can operate in a host of roles across the frontline, has yet to show that he has the quality to deliver consistently in the Premier League.

26/27 Premier League

Matias Fernandez-Pardo

Appearances

5

Starts

4

Goals

0

Big chances missed

2

Key passes per game

0.4

Big chances created

0

Assists

0

Pass accuracy

73%

The Belgian attacker has struggled in the Premier League since his move to England in the summer, and his finishing woes have already caused him issues, as he has missed both of the ‘big chances’ that have been created for him.

Jaissle handed the former Lille star a place in the line-up against Palace on Sunday, deploying him on the right side of the attack, but he was substituted after 56 minutes with no shots or chances created to his name.

The Belgian forward’s total lack of impact offensively is a major cause for concern, particularly given his struggles as a finisher in Ligue 1 last season, and his recent performances do not suggest that he is on the verge of turning his form around.

Newcastle should be able to expect relatively consistent performances, or at least some impact in the final third, for an attacking player who cost the club a whopping £51m.

Matias Fernandez-Pardo for Newcastle-2 REUTERS/Scott Heppell

Unfortunately, as was the case with Almiron, he is not delivering enough on the pitch to justify the money spent on his services, which is why the attacker is already on his way to becoming the next version of the Paraguayan flop.



Source link