GLP-1s, additional metabolic therapies, longevity-minded consumers and a trust gap: Where food CPG portfolios go from here
Six months into taking a GLP-1 medication, a shopper walks the snack aisle she knows by heart. She used to grab two family-size bags of chips and a box of cookies. Now she picks up a protein bar, checks the label, and puts it back.
Kearney analysts see GLP-1 users and longevity-minded consumers moving toward the same plate: fresher food, more protein, simpler ingredients, less sugar and alcohol. The shift is arriving just as price increases stop delivering growth.
Food CPGs are responding on three fronts: divesting, refocusing, and reformulating. Kearney experts explain how leaders can decide which consumers to serve and build portfolios that bring volume back.
Consumers are rewriting the menu
Federal plans, such as the phase-out of petroleum-based synthetic dyes, have put policy at the center of the healthier-food conversation. But Rob Dongoski, Global Lead of Agriculture and Food at Kearney, says consumers got there first. “People are changing the way they eat, and MAHA (Make America Healthy Again) is basically codifying that,” he explains.
Dyes are one piece of a broader demand for ingredients that sound like food rather than chemistry. GLP-1s are speeding that demand along. Gallup reports GLP-1 use has nearly quadrupled since 2024, and every user archetype in Kearney’s research cuts calories. Many also move away from salty and sugary snacks, ultra-processed foods, and soft drinks.
Medication is only one route to the same plate. According to the Kearney Consumer Institute, 65% of consumers say they’re increasing protein in their diets, 59% are working on gut health, and 59% are cutting back on alcohol, up from 55% in 2025.
Dongoski calls 2025 the year the industry accepted this shift in eating wasn’t a fad. “Gen Z and millennials are leading it, and they’re raising Gen Alpha with the same mindset,” he says.
Divest, refocus, reformulate: Three paths through a portfolio reset
Much of food CPGs’ recent growth came from price increases, and Dongoski says there’s little room left to take more. Katie Thomas, Lead of the Kearney Consumer Institute, agrees. “The price/value equation for many brands has slid out of balance,” she says. Volume has to come from somewhere, and consumers are moving away from many of the products that once delivered it.
Kearney sees three paths forward:
- Divest. The most decisive path is splitting up or selling the food businesses outright. As one example, Kellogg split in two in 2023, and both halves have since been sold, one to Ferrero and the other to Mars.
- Refocus. Shed what no longer fits to double down on what does. Unilever agreed in March 2026 to combine most of its food business, including Hellmann’s and Knorr, with McCormick. Thomas says companies can keep and build the brands “that have a strong foundational base and maintain a reason for being in a crowded space.”
- Reformulate. This is the broadest and hardest path. It often means adding protein and fiber, removing dyes, and rethinking products built for a different era of eating. Execution matters, too. Kraft Heinz sold about 50 million boxes of its reformulated macaroni and cheese before telling shoppers the recipe had changed, so they wouldn’t assume it tasted different.
Choosing among these paths, or combining them, starts with a more basic choice: which consumers to serve.
Choose your side of the K
Looking ahead, Dongoski sees food splitting along the K shape economists use to describe an uneven recovery. On one arm are consumers focused on health and longevity. On the other are those unwilling or unable to change, often because healthier food costs more.
Most shoppers don’t sort themselves neatly. When Kearney asked consumers to describe their approach to health, 63% chose “balance and moderation.” But when Kearney regrouped them by their constraints, motivations and habits, 50% landed in a group it calls “health on hold.”
“For many consumers, health is sidelined by choice or circumstance,” Thomas explains. “These consumers are seeking small wins, such as easy choices at the shelf and products that work hard for them.”
Helping those shoppers choose the right products takes work on two fronts:
- Placement. Better-for-you lines have moved down the center-store aisle but not out of it. Dongoski sees an opportunity for CPGs and retailers to move healthier products closer to the fresh perimeter or set them apart within the aisle.
- Labeling. Clear markers, similar to gluten-free shelf tags, can guide shoppers. Conagra already puts a “GLP-1 Friendly” badge on some Healthy Choice meals.
Trust fueled by results
Brand names don’t carry the weight they once did. Kearney’s research finds 86% of consumers say they care more about whether a product works than its brand name. Dongoski says that shift is testing a model CPGs have relied on for decades: measuring success by how many billion-dollar brands they own.
AI shopping tools can speed the shift by pointing out details such as formula changes, which makes every reformulation a trust test. Dongoski says the K split can help companies decide where change makes sense. “Reformulation is inevitable for products targeted toward the healthy leg of the K-shaped food economy,” he says. For products aimed at the other leg, he recommends reformulating as regulations require.
Rebuilding trust may also mean rethinking scale. Dongoski asks: “Instead of a billion-dollar brand, are you better off having 10 $100 million brands?”
Win consumers back at the shelf
As shoppers grow more skeptical and health-conscious, every label check is a chance to earn their trust. Food CPG leaders don’t have to earn it all at once. “This may be a classic ‘slow down to speed up’ environment,” Dongoski says. Companies may absorb some short-term financial strain while they realign portfolios with changing demand.
The first step is getting clear on which consumers to serve, then building products they’ll keep in the cart.
Get ahead of the next shift in how shoppers buy. Kearney’s upcoming GLP-1 research, expected in early December, will examine how different consumer archetypes are changing what they eat. Learn more.